Conformer Weighting and Differently Sized Cluster Weighting for Nicotine and Its Phosphorus Derivatives

Weighting methods applied to systems with many conformers have been broadly employed to calculate thermodynamic properties, structural characteristics, and populations. To better understand and test the sensitivity of conventional weighting methods, the conformational distributions of nicotine and its phosphorus-substituted derivatives are investigated. The weighting schemes used for this are all based on Boltzmann statistics. Classical Boltzmann factors based on the electronic energy and the Gibbs free energy are calculated at different quantum chemical levels of theory and compared to cluster weights obtained by the quantum cluster equilibrium method. Furthermore, the influence of the modified rigid-rotor-harmonic-oscillator (mRRHO) approximation on the cluster weights is investigated. The substitution of the nitrogen atom in the methylpyrrolidine ring by a phosphorus atom results in more monomer conformers and clusters being populated. The conformational distribution of the monomers remained stable at different levels of theory and weighting methods. However, going to dimers and trimers, we observe a significant influence of the level of theory, weighting method, and mRRHO cutoff on the populations of these clusters. We show that mRRHO cutoff values of 50 and 100 cm^-1 yield similar results, which is why 50 cm^-1 is recommended as a robust choice. Furthermore, we observe that the global minimum for ΔE₀ and ΔG varies in a few cases and that the global minimum is not always the dominantly occupied structure.