Prescription, precision, and decision in treatment planning

The goal of radiotherapy is to eradicate a tumor without causing severe damage to healthy tissues. Various published experiences have lead to the conclusion that an overall precision of +/- 5% on the absorbed doses, at any point in the patient, is required to meet this goal. Clear definitions of the method for specifying the absorbed dose and dose homogeneity throughout the target volume are essential, to facilitate communication, to improve the knowledge of dose-effect relations and to establish the necessary criteria for the optimization of treatment plans. Determination of the optimal energy is one of the most controversial problems in treatment plan optimization. It is clearly related to the criteria selected. A brief review of some criteria is proposed according to the tumor site. Computers may provide three-dimensional dose calculations for treatment conditions for which manual calculations are not feasible. Because the random errors are very small, computer calculations are often considered as exact although large risks of error are associated with each step of the calculation. The reduction of the overall uncertainty to the stated level of +/- 5% requires a constant effort from both radiotherapists and physicists at each step of treatment planning from basic definitions to dose distribution calculations.