How to Stabilize Carbenes in Enzyme Active Sites without Metal Ions

Carbenes are highly reactive compounds with unique value to synthetic chemistry. However, a small number of natural enzymes have been shown to utilize carbene chemistry, and artificial enzymes engineered with directed evolution required transition metal ions to stabilize the carbene intermediates. To facilitate the design of broader classes of enzymes that can take advantage of the rich carbene chemistry, it is thus important to better understand how to stabilize carbene species in enzyme active sites without metal ions. Motivated by our recent studies of the anaerobic ergothioneine biosynthesis enzyme EanB, we examine carbene-protein interaction with both cluster models and QM/MM simulations. The cluster calculations find that an N-heterocyclic carbene interacts strongly with polar and positively charged protein motifs. In particular, the interaction between a guanidinium group and carbene is as strong as ∼30 kcal/mol, making arginine a great choice for the preferential stabilization of carbenes. We also compare the WT EanB and its mutant in which the key tyrosine was replaced by a non-natural analogue (F2Tyr) using DFTB3/MM simulations. The calculations suggest that the carbene intermediate in the F2Tyr mutant is more stable than that in the WT enzyme by ∼3.5 kcal/mol, due to active site rearrangements that enable a nearby arginine to better stabilize the carbene in the mutant. Overall, the current work lays the foundation for the pursuit of enzyme designs that can take advantage of the unique chemistry offered by carbenes without the requirement of metal ions.