The ill physician who self-discloses: What do patients think?

Physicians with a serious illness face difficult decisions about revealing this sensitive information to patients. Self-disclosure of illness is a largely unexplored topic, particularly from the patient's perspective.

To learn about patients' emotions and reactions to their family physician's sharing with them about having a major illness.

The study was carried out in a family practice office in a suburb of Jerusalem, beginning the day that a family physician returned to work after a prolonged illness. A questionnaire study was performed with nine closed and four open questions relating to patients' reactions to learning about the illness. The questionnaire was distributed to 200 consecutive patients ages 18 years or older. Data extraction, compilation, and content analysis were performed to elicit and categorise major themes and issues that arose.

A total of 82% of the patients were pleased that the physician shared the information with them and none were displeased. Patients expressed a wide range of reactions to being told of the illness by the physician himself, among them: empathy, surprise, appreciation, pride, criticism, comfort/discomfort, and closeness. The value of sharing personal experience and the unique connection with the family physician were emphasised.

Physician self-disclosure of major illnesses to patients can reveal the physician's humanity, encourage empathy on the part of patients and strengthen the physician-patient relationship. This report adds to current knowledge about when to share this powerful information with patients and highlights the topic's importance in the education of future doctors.