Representation of evidence-based clinical practice guideline recommendations on FHIR

Various formalisms have been developed to represent clinical practice guideline recommendations in a computer-interpretable way. However, none of the existing formalisms leverage the structured and computable information that emerge from the evidence-based guideline development process. Thus, we here propose a FHIR-based format that uses computer-interpretable representations of the knowledge artifacts that emerge during the process of evidence-based guideline development to directly serve as the basis of evidence-based recommendations.

We identified the information required to represent evidence-based clinical practice guideline recommendations and reviewed the knowledge artifacts emerging during the evidence-based guideline development process. We then conducted a consensus-based design process with domain experts to develop an information model for guideline recommendation representation that is structurally aligned to the evidence-based guideline recommendation development process and a corresponding representation based on FHIR resources developed for evidence-based medicine (EBMonFHIR). The resulting recommendations were modelled and represented in conformance with the FHIR Clinical Guidelines (CPG-on-FHIR) implementation guide.

The information model of evidence-based clinical guideline recommendations and its EBMonFHIR-/CPG-on-FHIR-based representation contain the clinical contents of individual guideline recommendations, a set of metadata for the recommendations, the ratings for the recommendations (e.g., strength of recommendation, certainty of overall evidence), the ratings of certainty of evidence for individual outcomes (e.g., risk of bias) and links to the underlying evidence (systematic reviews based on primary studies). We created profiles and an implementation guide for all FHIR resources required to represent the knowledge artifacts generated during evidence-based guideline development and their re-use as the basis for recommendations and used the profiles to implement an exemplary clinical guideline recommendation.

The FHIR implementation guide presented here can be used to directly link the evidence assessment process of evidence-based guideline recommendation development, i.e. systematic reviews and evidence grading, and the underlying evidence from primary studies to the resulting guideline recommendations. This not only allows the evidence on which recommendations are based on to be evaluated transparently and critically, but also enables guideline developers to leverage computable evidence in a more direct way to facilitate the generation of computer-interpretable guideline recommendations.