A Competition of Secondary and Primary Nucleation Controls Amyloid Fibril Formation of the Parathyroid Hormone

Functional amyloids belong to an increasing class of non-toxic biologic material, in contrast to the prominent disease-related amyloids. Herein, this work reports on the fibril formation of the parathyroid hormone PTH₈₄ as a representative candidate following the same generic principles of primary and secondary nucleation. Employing Thioflavin T monitored kinetics analyses and negative-staining transmission electron microscopy, an intricate, concentration dependent behavior of time dependent generation and morphologies of PTH₈₄ fibrils are found. While at low peptide concentrations, fibril formation is driven by surface catalyzed secondary nucleation, an increased amount of peptides cause a negative feedback on fibril elongation and secondary nucleation. Moreover, the source of primary nuclei is found to regulate the overall macroscopic fibrillation. As a consequence, the concentration dependent competition of primary versus secondary nucleation pathways is found to dominate the mechanism of fibril generation. This work is able to hypothesize an underlying monomer-oligomer equilibrium providing high-order species for primary nucleation and, additionally, negatively affecting the available monomer pool.