Related Experiment Video
Updated: Aug 2, 2025

08:16
Movement Retraining using Real-time Feedback of Performance
Published on: January 17, 2013
13.5K
Motion-Based Extrinsic Sensor-to-Sensor Calibration: Effect of Reference Frame Selection for New and Existing
Tuomas Välimäki1, Bharath Garigipati1, Reza Ghabcheloo1
1Automation Technology and Mechanical Engineering, Tampere University, FI-33720 Tampere, Finland.
Sensors (Basel, Switzerland)
|April 13, 2023
Summary
Choosing the right reference frame is crucial for sensor calibration, especially with noisy data. This study reveals that reference frame selection significantly impacts accuracy, often more than the calibration algorithm itself.
Area of Science:
- Robotics
- Computer Vision
- Sensor Fusion
Background:
- Sensor-to-sensor extrinsic calibration is vital for multi-sensor systems.
- Motion-based hand-eye calibration is a common approach.
- Sensor trajectories often contain noise, affecting calibration accuracy.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate the impact of reference frame selection on sensor-to-sensor extrinsic calibration.
- To identify optimal reference frame selection strategies under various noise conditions.
- To compare proposed cost functions against state-of-the-art methods.
Main Methods:
- Simulations with varying noise levels were performed.
- Real-world data from the KITTI dataset was used for validation.
- Four state-of-the-art methods and two novel cost functions were evaluated.
Main Results:
- One proposed cost function with outlier rejection significantly improved performance with outliers.
- Reference frame selection yielded greater performance gains than algorithm selection.
- Commonly used reference frame selection methods in literature were found to be suboptimal.
Conclusions:
- Careful reference frame selection is critical for robust sensor calibration.
- Outlier rejection in cost functions enhances calibration accuracy.
- Relative error metrics are unreliable for assessing calibration performance.
Related Concept Videos
Inertial Frames of Reference
7.2K
Newton’s first law is usually considered to be a statement about reference frames. It provides a method for identifying a special type of reference frame: the inertial reference frame. In principle, we can make the net force on a body zero. If its velocity relative to a given frame is constant, then that frame is said to be inertial. So, by definition, an inertial reference frame is a reference frame where Newton's first law holds valid. Newton's first law applies to objects with...
7.2K
Non-inertial Frames of Reference
6.0K
A reference frame accelerating or decelerating relative to an inertial frame is a non-inertial frame. To help understand this, consider what taking off in an airplane, turning a corner in a car, riding a merry-go-round, and the circular motion of a tropical cyclone all have in common. All these systems are accelerating, decelerating, or rotating relative to the Earth; hence, they all are non-inertial frames. All these systems exhibit inertial forces, which merely seem to arise from motion,...
6.0K
Relative Motion Analysis using Rotating Axes
493
Consider a component AB undergoing a linear motion. Along with a linear motion, point B also rotates around point A. To comprehend this complex movement, position vectors for both points A and B are established using a stationary reference frame.
However, to express the relative position of point B relative to point A, an additional frame of reference, denoted as x'y', is necessary. This additional frame not only translates but also rotates relative to the fixed frame, making it...
However, to express the relative position of point B relative to point A, an additional frame of reference, denoted as x'y', is necessary. This additional frame not only translates but also rotates relative to the fixed frame, making it...
493
Relative Motion Analysis using Rotating Axes-Problem Solving
428
Consider a crane whose telescopic boom rotates with an angular velocity of 0.04 rad/s and angular acceleration of 0.02 rad/s2. Along with the rotation, the boom also extends linearly with a uniform speed of 5 m/s. The extension of the boom is measured at point D, which is measured with respect to the fixed point C on the other end of the boom. For the given instant, the distance between points C and D is 60 meters.
Here, in order to determine the magnitude of velocity and acceleration for point...
Here, in order to determine the magnitude of velocity and acceleration for point...
428

