Diagnostic Accuracy of Transesophageal Echocardiographic Commissural-Biplane Approach in Identifying Mitral Valve...

Transesophageal echocardiography (TEE) conventional multiplane approach (MPA) and the newly proposed commissural-biplane approach (CBA) are the recommended algorithms for identifying the affected mitral valve (MV) segments in the setting of mitral regurgitation. To date, there are no reports to address the diagnostic performance of CBA. In this study we aim to analyze the diagnostic accuracy of CBA and MPA in comparison with three-dimensional echocardiographic findings in patients with severe mitral regurgitation.

We prospectively enrolled 102 patients with severe mitral regurgitation. All patients underwent systematic TEE assessment of MV before surgical intervention to define the affected MV segments/scallops. The standard MPA includes 4-chamber, 2-chamber, long-axis, and commissural views; CBA was performed by obtaining the bicommissural view and simultaneous biplane imaging of the medial, middle, and lateral MV aspects. The findings of both TEE approaches were compared with three-dimensional TEE data to assess the diagnostic accuracy of MPA and CBA.

The mean patient age was (65 ± 11) years, and 37 (36.3%) were female. We found that CBA had an overall diagnostic accuracy between 88% and 97% in identifying the abnormal MV scallops; in contrast, MPA accuracy ranged between 82% and 95%. The CBA and MPA were the least accurate in identifying the P3 scallop-88% and 82% respectively; however, both were the most accurate in assessing the A2 segment-95% and 97%, respectively. The sensitivity of identifying commissural abnormalities was 80% with CBA and 30% with MPA. Three-dimensional TEE was found to have a strong agreement with CBA (averaged kappa of 0.81, P < .0001) and a modest agreement with MPA (averaged kappa of 0.61, P < .0001) in identifying abnormal anterior or posterior segments. On the other hand, three-dimensional TEE had a weak agreement with CBA (kappa of 0.43, P < .0001) and no agreement with MPA (kappa of 0.14, P = .153) in the assessment of commissural involvements.

The CBA is more accurate than the MPA in the assessment of MV commissural involvement. Given the accuracy differences of the 2 approaches for specific leaflet/scallops, a comprehensive evaluation using both approaches is recommended for all MV scallop assessments.