Comparison of alveolar bone thickness and height after slow expansion using quad-helix or clear aligners

The study was conducted to investigate the thickness and height of the alveolar bone of individual teeth after slow maxillary expansion (SME) with quad helix or clear aligner appliances and hypothesized that there is no difference in buccal alveolar bone thickness or heights in patients treated by either quad helix or clear aligners.

This is a retrospective study; the records of 22 patients treated between December 2019 to April 2020 by dental arch expansion using either clear aligners or quad helix appliances were retrieved and studied. The results obtained through cone beam computed tomography (CBCTs) before and immediately after maxillary expansion (2 + 1 mm per side) were analyzed (11 in the Quad Helix group and 11 in the clear aligner). The data collected was analyzed using linear and angular measurements obtained through On-demand 3D App software. Furthermore, Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 25.0 was used to present the findings by mean and standard deviations, and Scheffe's test was applied for comparing forces.

The results showed that the mean age of patients in the clear aligner group and Quad Helix was 16.27 ± 0.56 years and 15.5 ± 1.53 years, respectively. There was no difference in buccal alveolar bone thickness or heights in patients treated by either quad helix or clear aligners. This is due to the findings that suggest that there was a decrease in bone height and bone width when treated with a quad helix as compared to clear alignment.

It can be concluded that the quad helix SME treatment affects alveolar bone integrity; therefore, clear aligners might be better for treating patients than the quad helix.