Garnet crystallization does not drive oxidation at arcs

Arc magmas, the building blocks of continental crust, are depleted in total iron (Fe), have higher ratios of oxidized Fe to total Fe (Fe³⁺/∑Fe), and record higher oxygen fugacities (fO₂'s) compared with magmas erupted at mid-ocean ridges. Garnet crystallization could explain these observations if garnet removes substantial amounts of Fe²⁺, but not Fe³⁺, from magma, yet this model for continental crust generation has never been tested experimentally. Analysis of garnets and melts in laboratory experiments show that the compatibilities of Fe²⁺ and Fe³⁺ in garnet are of similar magnitudes. Our results indicate that fractional crystallization of garnet-bearing cumulates will remove 20% of total Fe from primary arc basalts but negligibly alter the Fe³⁺/∑Fe ratio and fO₂ of the melt. Garnet crystallization is unlikely to be responsible for the relatively oxidized nature of basaltic arc magmas or the Fe-depletion trend observed in continental crust.