Reducing herbicide input and optimizing spray method can minimize nontarget impacts on native grassland plant species

Invasive plants threaten biodiversity worldwide and effective management must control the target invader while conserving biodiversity. Herbicide is often used to control invasive plants, but potential negative impacts on biodiversity have led to spot spraying being recommended over boom spraying to minimize the exposure of nontarget species to chemicals. We examined the influence of herbicide application methods on off-target plant communities in threatened temperate grasslands of southeastern Australia, where spraying with the broadleaf herbicide fluroxypr is commonly used to control St. John's wort, Hypericum perforatum L. It is well established that fluroxypr effectively controls H. perforatum but few studies have examined its impact on native forbs. A spray drift experiment using water-sensitive cards indicated that ground surface coverage was higher for spot spraying (91%-99%) than for boom spraying (5%-31%). We established a replicated, 3-year, before-after-control-impact experiment across 48 1-m² quadrats to determine how three herbicide application methods (spot spray, fine boom and coarse boom) affected nontarget native forbs, the group most likely to be affected by broadleaf herbicides. This experiment was conducted in grasslands where H. perforatum was almost absent, so responses would reflect the direct impacts of the chemical, rather than structural changes resulting from removal of the target invader. Spot spraying decreased the probability of occurrence of native leguminous forbs, while increasing the occurrence of exotic leguminous forbs and the richness of all exotic species and exotic annual forbs. Spot spraying reduced the occurrence of the native Desmodium varians and the abundance of the native Chrysocephalum apiculatum. During this 3-year study, native species appeared to be impacted either directly by fluroxypr or indirectly by increased competition with exotic species. Where herbicide application is deemed crucial in these grasslands, we recommend boom spraying when H. perforatum density is moderate to high. Spot spraying should only be used when the density of H. perforatum is very low. Given the regional variation in H. perforatum density, the spatial scale of invasion, soil depth, and conservation values, we present a decision tree to assist managers in evaluating the costs and benefits of chemical control, indicating situations where alternative or modified methods could be used.