Incidental recognition reveals attentional tradeoffs shaped by categorical similarity

Search efficiency suffers when observers look for multiple targets or a single imprecisely defined target. These conditions prevent a narrow target template, resulting in improved delayed distractor recognition. In our first experiment with hybrid visual and memory search, we investigated the interaction of target variety and target number on search efficiency. Results supported the hypothesis that numerous targets impair search efficiency much more when targets are unrelated. These efficiency impairments were linked to distractor processing, indicated by increased delayed recognition. A second experiment manipulated target-distractor similarity to determine whether prioritization of target-defining features is totally eliminated in search for eight unrelated targets. For related and unrelated targets alike, recognition declined for distractors bearing less resemblance to targets and more to each other. This suggests templates for unrelated targets successfully prioritize relevant features at some stage of attention. Avoidance of random distractors was stronger when targets were related, at the price of slower, more error-prone identification of within-category distractors. Within-category processing difficulty for related targets likely stems from categorical interference as previously demonstrated in recognition memory. Thus, target variety versus homogeneity afforded different advantages and limitations depending on target number, target-distractor, and distractor-distractor resemblance. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).