The Benefit of Cost-Transparency Calculators Does Not Extend to Vascular Surgery Patients

In 2021, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) mandated that every hospital create a publicly available webtool for pricing various medical services in an effort to give patients transparency in regard to their health care expenses and allow patients to "shop around" to receive the care most fitting their budget. Our objective is to investigate the utility this mandate provides for vascular surgery patients.

Standardized searches were performed to find patient cost calculators for Newsweek's Top 50 Hospitals in the United States. If the webtool was found, a list of standardized searches were performed to investigate whether the tool listed prices for the following vascular procedures: Arteriovenous fistula (AVF), varicose vein procedures, and Endovascular Aneurysm Repair (EVAR).

Of the 50 hospitals included, all had an easily accessible web-based cost estimator tool. The average time to find the cost estimator was 33.27 sec. Of these 50 hospitals, 10% provided cost information on AVF surgery, 12% provided cost information on varicose vein procedures, and 0% provided information on EVAR. There was no difference in the hospital's likelihood to report a price based on region of the United States. Average preinsurance price for AVF surgery was $11,933.61 and $22,191 for vein procedures.

In conclusion, despite good adherence to the CMS mandate requiring a publicly available pricing tool, these tools provide little to no information for vascular surgery patients. Overall, this discrepancy places vascular surgery patients at a significant disadvantage. As such, vascular patients do not have access to the knowledge necessary to financially prepare for surgery, and furthermore, they are not afforded the luxury to choose where to have procedures performed based on price variability. Hopefully this research will encourage hospitals to broaden the scope of their cost calculators to allow it to benefit all patients.