A Tissue Dielectric Constant Evaluation of Knee Edema: A Retrospective Intra-rater Reliability and Association Study...

This research compared the reliability and association of tissue dielectric constant (TDC) measures of knee edema to circumferential measurements of knee girth recorded as part of a physical therapy examination.

Twenty adults having observable unilateral knee edema were enrolled. A single examiner measured edematous knee swelling with a TDC device and a tape measure across two visits. The presence of edema was recorded as a positive number in reporting side-to-side differences and a positive percentage in documenting change over time. Intra-rater reliability of the measures was assessed with an intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC). Percent change in edema was evaluated independently for both methods using a paired t-test, and the association between measures was assessed by a Pearson's statistic.

Both measures were reliable (ICC ≥ 0.81), and both detected a significant percentage decrease (p < 0.05) in edema across visits. The TDC measure changed by 8.3%, an amount nearly four times larger compared to knee girth (2.4%). The subsequent follow-up comparison revealed an inverse relationship (p = 0.049; r = -0.44) between the two percent change measurements of edema.

The two methods capture different physical attributes of edema. The TDC records the water content of the tissue, while the use of a tape measure records circumferential limb girth. The TDC measurement was reliable and more responsive in detecting a percentage decrease in knee edema in comparison to a circumferential measure of knee girth. The TDC method may have wider use in directly measuring edema in other tissue structures and regions of the body.