Recruitment of a Middling Promiscuous Enzyme Drives Adaptive Metabolic Evolution in Escherichia coli

A key step in metabolic pathway evolution is the recruitment of promiscuous enzymes to perform new functions. Despite the recognition that promiscuity is widespread in biology, factors dictating the preferential recruitment of one promiscuous enzyme over other candidates are unknown. Escherichia coli contains four sugar kinases that are candidates for recruitment when the native glucokinase machinery is deleted-allokinase (AlsK), manno(fructo)kinase (Mak), N-acetylmannosamine kinase (NanK), and N-acetylglucosamine kinase (NagK). The catalytic efficiencies of these enzymes are 103- to 105-fold lower than native glucokinases, ranging from 2,400 M-1 s-1 for the most active candidate, NagK, to 15 M-1 s-1 for the least active candidate, AlsK. To investigate the relationship between catalytic activities of promiscuous enzymes and their recruitment, we performed adaptive evolution of a glucokinase-deficient E. coli strain to restore glycolytic metabolism. We observed preferential recruitment of NanK via a trajectory involving early mutations that facilitate glucose uptake and amplify nanK transcription, followed by nonsynonymous substitutions in NanK that enhance the enzyme's promiscuous glucokinase activity. These substitutions reduced the native activity of NanK and reduced organismal fitness during growth on an N-acetylated carbon source, indicating that enzyme recruitment comes at a cost for growth on other substrates. Notably, the two most active candidates, NagK and Mak, were not recruited, suggesting that catalytic activity alone does not dictate evolutionary outcomes. The results highlight our lack of knowledge regarding biological drivers of enzyme recruitment and emphasize the need for a systems-wide approach to identify factors facilitating or constraining this important adaptive process.