Comparative Analysis of Therapeutic Outcomes Between Modified Loop Plate and Hook Plate for Treating Acute...

This study aimed to evaluate the clinical efficacy of an enhanced minimally invasive NICE joint technique combined with dual adjustable loop steel plate internal fixation for treating acute acromioclavicular joint dislocation.

A retrospective analysis was conducted on 63 surgical patients treated with acute acromioclavicular joint dislocation from May 2017 to March 2022. Among them, 33 cases were treated with the clavicle hook plate, and 30 cases were treated with the minimally invasive loop plate. We compared hospitalization duration, incision length, surgical duration, intraoperative bleeding, visual analogue pain scale scores, shoulder joint Constant scores at 6 months before and after surgery, and the incidence of complications between the two groups.

The comparison between the two groups, including hospitalization duration, incision length, surgical duration, intraoperative bleeding volume, and shoulder joint Constant score at 6 months post-surgery, revealed statistically significant differences where the loop plate group had better results. One case (1/33) experienced postoperative complications in the hook plate group, including screw loosening and plate failure. Additionally, there were 8 cases (8/33) of subacromial osteolysis, 10 cases (10/33) of acromial impact, and 5 cases (5/33) of residual shoulder pain. Conversely, only 1 case (1/30) in the loop plate group had residual shoulder pain.

The surgical technique involving the reconstruction of the coracoclavicular ligament using an enhanced minimally invasive NICE junction combined with double adjustable loop steel plate placement in the clavicular small bone canal is characterized by simplicity, safety, minimal invasiveness, excellent functional recovery, fewer complications, and superior clinical efficacy compared to clavicular hook steel plates.