Pressure threshold for inhibition of dense granular film opening

Controlling the stability of a granular film is essential in a wide range of industrial applications, from aerated building materials to recovering ore by flotation and treating wastewater. We therefore carry out experiments of granular film opening where particles of hundred of micrometers above random close packing zip the two interfaces of a soap film which liquid pressure is controlled. We create a hole at the center of this dense granular film and, surprisingly, we observe that the opening is not always inhibited. Different behaviours are identified: total bursting of the granular film, intermittent opening and jammed state for which the hole does not evolve. The liquid pressure drives the transition from one opening behaviour to another. Lower is the liquid pressure, more jammed is the system. The critical pressure transition scales as the surface tension over the particle size until the finite size of the granular film is only few tens of the particle size. Ultimately we evidence that spontaneous hole in thin film between particle do not lead to the granular film failure.