Calcium-proton and calcium-magnesium antagonisms in calmodulin: microcalorimetric and potentiometric analyses

Microcalorimetry, pH potentiometry, and direct binding studies by equilibrium dialysis or gel filtration were performed to determine the thermodynamic functions delta Ho, delta Go, and delta So guiding the interactions of Ca2+, Mg2+, and H+ with bovine brain calmodulin. At pH 7.5, Ca2+ and Mg2+ binding are both endothermic with enthalpy changes of 19.5 and 72.8 kJ X (mol of calmodulin)-1, respectively. These enthalpy changes are identical for each of the four ion-binding domains. The affinity constants also are identical with intrinsic values of 10(5) M-1 for Ca2+ and 140 M-1 for Mg2+. Ca2+ and Mg2+ do not compete for the same binding sites: at high concentrations of both ions, a calmodulin-Ca4-Mg4 species is formed with an enthalpy value of 24.4 kJ X mol-1 with respect to calmodulin-Ca4 and -28.8 kJ X mol-1 with respect to calmodulin-Mg4. Moreover, in the presence of high concentrations of Ca2+, the affinity of each of the four ion-binding domains in calmodulin for Mg2+ is decreased by a factor of 4 and vice versa, indicative of negative free-energy coupling between Ca2+ and Mg2+ binding. Protons antagonize Ca2+ and Mg2+ binding in a different manner. Ca2+-H+ antagonism is identical in each of the four Ca2+-binding domains in the pH range 7.5-5.2. Our analyses suggest that three chemical geometries, probably carboxyl-carboxylate interactions, are responsible for this antagonism with ionization constants of 10(6.2) M-1 in the metal-free protein. Mg2+-H+ antagonism also is identical for each of the Mg2+-binding sites but is qualitatively different from Ca2+-H+ antagonism.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)