Genetic determinism and hemispheric influence in hair whorl formation

The mechanisms determining the laterality and the rotation direction of hair whorls are unknown. Here we report observations on twins investigating the genetic bases of whorl pattern formation. Knowing that vortex phenomena may depend on geographic effects, we also provide comparative data on whorls from children born in the Northern hemisphere (France) versus children born in the Southern hemisphere (Chile).

We retrospectively included children from three populations: (1) Northern hemisphere general population, (2) Southern hemisphere general population, and (3) same-sex Northern hemisphere twins. We recorded whorl rotation direction (clockwise, counterclockwise), whorl position (left, right, central) and twinning type. Univariate logistic models were used to screen for associations between rotation direction and whorl position. For twins, the variable of interest was binary, i.e. same rotation direction (reference class) or opposite directions for each twin pair. For controls, all single combinations were included as virtual twins, and compared to real twins. Odds ratios (OR) were compared for both hemispheres, for real twins and virtual (control) twins.

Seventy-four (37 pairs) twins and 50 children from the general population of each hemisphere were included. The OR for opposite rotation directions between two twins was ≠1 (p = 0.017), meaning that whorls rotated preferentially in the same direction in twins. ORs were <1 for Northern and Southern hemispheres, meaning that whorls rotated preferentially in the same direction in simulated twins. OR for the Northern hemisphere (0.04 [0.03; 0.05]) was less than the OR for the Southern hemisphere (0.28 [0.24; 0.32]) with no confidence interval superimposition, indicating than counterclockwise whorls were more frequent in the Southern hemisphere (p < 0.001).

We suggest that hair whorl formation is a genetically determined developmental process that can be influenced by extrinsic environmental factors. Our results furthermore underline the general importance of studies focused on limit phenomena that can provide insights on general developmental mechanisms. We plead for large-scale epidemiological assessments of hair whorls in several Northern and Southern hemisphere populations to confirm these surprising findings suggesting significant modulations of craniofacial development by geographic effects.