The Relationship of Self-identified Weight Status With Perceived Mental and Physical Health

This study examined whether individuals with higher weight (body mass index in the overweight or obesity range) self-identified as having overweight or obesity (Ow/Ob). The study also examined whether self-identifying as having Ow/Ob was associated with perceived mental health, perceived physical health, depression, and eating disorder psychopathology.

Four study groups were created: those with Ow/Ob who self-identified as having Ow/Ob (Ow/Ob+), those with Ow/Ob who did not self-identify as having Ow/Ob (Ow/Ob-), those with core features of binge-eating disorder (BED) and Ow/Ob, and those with bulimia nervosa (BN) and Ow/Ob. Analyses of variance compared study groups on perceived health, depression, and eating disorder psychopathology.

The BED and BN groups were more likely to self-identify as having overweight/obesity compared with Ow/Ob groups without eating disorders. The Ow/Ob- group had the best-perceived health and the lowest levels of eating disorder psychopathology and depression compared with the other groups. The Ow/Ob+ group had better perceived mental health than the BED and BN groups but did not differ significantly from the Ow/Ob- group in perceived mental health. Perceived physical health in the Ow/Ob+ group was better than in the BED group and worse than in the Ow/Ob- group. The Ow/Ob+ group had higher levels of eating disorder psychopathology than the Ow/Ob- group.

Self-identifying as having obesity is associated with eating disorder psychopathology as well as poorer perceived mental and physical health. Providers should engage patients in discussions about their weight with the understanding that self-identifying as having overweight or obesity might indicate the presence of eating disorder psychopathology. Future clinical research should investigate the directionality or possible bidirectionality of this relationship.