Natural cytotoxic cells and tumor necrosis factor activate similar lytic mechanisms

The lytic activity of natural cytotoxic (NC) cells has several characteristics which clearly distinguish it from other cell-mediated lytic activities and from most soluble cytolytic factors. An exception is the lytic activity mediated by tumor necrosis factor (TNF). In this paper, we report a detailed comparison of NC and TNF lysis of target cells which are used as prototype NC targets or TNF targets, and show that the two cytolytic activities have very similar, if not identical, lytic mechanisms. We present data showing that target cells which are NC-sensitive are also TNF-sensitive and that target cells which are NC-resistant are also TNF-resistant. Moreover, cells selected either in vivo or in vitro for NC resistance are selected for TNF resistance, and cells selected for TNF resistance are selected for NC resistance. The analysis of the kinetics of 51Cr release mediated by NC cells or by TNF show that both activities affect similar kinetics, in that there is no cell lysis for several hours after targets and effectors first interact. However, NC and TNF lytic activities can be distinguished. By using the cell lines 10ME or B/C-N as targets, it can be shown that whereas NC-mediated lysis is dependent on protein synthesis, TNF-mediated lysis is not. We also show that targets which are resistant to NC-mediated lysis because they express a protein synthesis-dependent resistance mechanism also require protein synthesis to resist TNF-mediated lysis, suggesting that the same resistance mechanism protects cells against both NC cells and TNF. Together, these data strongly support the hypothesis that NC cells and TNF activate the same lytic mechanism within target cells and that TNF may mediate the lytic activity of NC effector cells.