Complex oiling-out behavior of procaine with stable and metastable liquid phases

During the crystallization of a solute from solvent(s), spontaneous liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) might occur, under certain conditions. This phenomenon, colloquially referred to as "oiling-out" in the pharmaceutical industry, often leads to undesired outcomes, including undesired particle properties, encrustation, ineffective impurity rejection, and excessively long process time. Therefore, it is critical to understand the thermodynamic driving force and phase boundaries of this phenomenon, such that rational strategies can be developed to avoid oiling-out or minimize its negative impact. In this study, we systematically evaluated the oiling-out behavior of procaine, a low melting point drug, in the solvent systems heptane, and ethanol-heptane as a function of temperature and solvent composition. In the procaine-heptane binary system, we observed a region where the LLPS is metastable with respect to crystallization, which is most commonly observed in the crystallization of modern active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs); however, we also identified a region of the phase diagram where the LLPS is stable with respect to crystallization, and therefore will persist indefinitely. In the procaine-ethanol-heptane ternary system we identified five different regions, including a homogeneous liquid (L) region, two solid-liquid (SL_I and SL_II) regions, a liquid-liquid (L_IL_II) region, and a solid-liquid-liquid (SL_IL_II) region. The binary and ternary phase diagrams were also predicted using a state-of-the-art thermodynamic model: the SAFT-γ-Mie equation of state, and the results were compared with experimental data. Our findings highlight the complexity of oiling-out behavior. This work also represents a combined modeling and experimental platform to identify phase boundaries that will enable rational selection of strategies to crystallize active pharmaceutical ingredients with oiling-out risks.