Unconventional Error Cancellation Explains the Success of Hartree-Fock Density Functional Theory for Barrier Heights

Energy barriers, which control the rates of chemical reactions, are seriously underestimated by computationally efficient semilocal approximations for the exchange-correlation energy. The accuracy of a semilocal density functional approximation is strongly boosted for reaction barrier heights by evaluating that approximation non-self-consistently on Hartree-Fock electron densities, which has been known for ∼30 years. The conventional explanation is that the Hartree-Fock theory yields the more accurate density. This work presents a benchmark Kohn-Sham inversion of accurate coupled-cluster densities for the reaction H₂ + F → HHF → H + HF and finds a strong, understandable cancellation between positive (excessively overcorrected) density-driven and large negative functional-driven errors (expected from stretched radical bonds in the transition state) within this Hartree-Fock density functional theory. This confirms earlier conclusions (Kaplan, A. D., et al. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2023, 19, 532-543) based on 76 barrier heights and three less reliable, but less expensive, fully nonlocal density functional proxies for the exact density.