Optimal Performance Objectives in the Highly Conserved Bone Morphogenetic Protein Signaling Pathway

Throughout development, complex networks of cell signaling pathways drive cellular decision-making across different tissues and contexts. The transforming growth factor β (TGF-β) pathways, including the BMP/Smad pathway, play crucial roles in these cellular responses. However, as the Smad pathway is used reiteratively throughout the life cycle of all animals, its systems-level behavior varies from one context to another, despite the pathway connectivity remaining nearly constant. For instance, some cellular systems require a rapid response, while others require high noise filtering. In this paper, we examine how the BMP- Smad pathway balances trade-offs among three such systems-level behaviors, or "Performance Objectives (POs)": response speed, noise amplification, and the sensitivity of pathway output to receptor input. Using a Smad pathway model fit to human cell data, we show that varying non-conserved parameters (NCPs) such as protein concentrations, the Smad pathway can be tuned to emphasize any of the three POs and that the concentration of nuclear phosphatase has the greatest effect on tuning the POs. However, due to competition among the POs, the pathway cannot simultaneously optimize all three, but at best must balance trade-offs among the POs. We applied the multi-objective optimization concept of the Pareto Front, a widely used concept in economics to identify optimal trade-offs among various requirements. We show that the BMP pathway efficiently balances competing POs across species and is largely Pareto optimal. Our findings reveal that varying the concentration of NCPs allows the Smad signaling pathway to generate a diverse range of POs. This insight identifies how signaling pathways can be optimally tuned for each context.