The bevel effect: a prospective, randomized investigation into needle design in dental intraligamentary anesthesia

This in vivo study aimed to assess the impact of needle bevel design on puncture pain, anesthetic success, and mechanical deformations in intraligamentary injection (ILA) cases, comparing a short triple facet cut (STF) to a triple lancet cut (TL) after single or repetitive use.

In a prospective single-blind trial, 200 ILA needles (STF, n = 100; TL, n = 100) were randomly assigned for dental procedures. Patients received ILA either with STF or TL needles, used once (group A; n = 50 each) or repeatedly (group B; n = 50). Puncture pain was assessed using a numerical rating scale (NRS). Anesthetic success was determined via cold spray (yes/no), and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) analyzed needle tip deformations.

Puncture pain did not significantly differ between STF and TL, regardless of needle use or injection area. Success rates were comparable in single use (82% STF vs. 79% TL; p > 0.05). For repetitive use, STF exhibited a significantly higher success rate (80% vs. 69%; p = 0.012). Mechanical deformations were prevalent in 97.5% of needles, with TL showing greater deformations than STF after single and repeated uses. Barbs were more common in TL (90/100) than STF (84/100), with a higher relative risk for barbed-like deformation in TL (RR single use: 1.26; p < 0.001; multiple use: 7.87, p < 0.001).

The short triple facet-designed bevel demonstrated significantly less mechanical deformation, suggesting potential advantages in maintaining needle lumen patency.

The intraligamentary needle bevel design is linked to mechanical deformation and anesthetic success after repetitive use, but not to puncture pain.