Modifications to the WHISTLE Flap Procedure for Correction of Secondary Cleft Lip Deformities

The whistle deformity, a deficiency of tissue in the central upper lip, is a consequential outcome of primary cleft lip repair. Among multiple described reconstructive options, the wide-hinged island swing transposition labial enhancement (WHISTLE) flap procedure by Grewal et al has been shown to be a reliable technique that restores the continuity of the orbicularis oris muscle and creates a more natural appearing tubercle and central lip element. This article aims to refine the WHISTLE flap procedure with the addition of tailored mucomuscular flaps and an upper lip-lengthening mucosal Z-plasty.

A total of 11 patients with a whistle deformity were examined. All underwent the WHISTLE flap procedure with tailored mucomuscular flaps and a mucosal Z-plasty. The patients were followed for a period of from 6 to 51.5 months. Pre- and postoperative photographs were used for objective outcome comparison.

From 2018 to 2023, a total of 11 patients with a whistle deformity were included in the final cohort, comprised four bilateral and seven unilateral cleft lips. Ten cases (90.1%) resulted in satisfactory postoperative cosmetic appearance and did not require further interventions. A single patient with a significant preoperative discrepancy between the upper and lower lip volumes had a postoperative residual deformity. None of the patients demonstrated any functional deficits associated with the procedure.

The WHISTLE flap procedure with the proposed individual tailoring of the mucomuscular flap and Z-plasty for mucosal scar lengthening has excellent cosmetic outcomes and can be considered as the primary treatment modality in most patients with a whistle deformity.