Multifocal Papillary Thyroid Carcinomas With Discordant Molecular Drivers: Emphasizing the Morphology and Collision...

Multifocal papillary thyroid carcinomas (PTCs) are common and the majority of the tumors harbor mutual BRAF p.V600E mutation. This study aimed to investigate a contemporary series of multifocal PTCs with discordant molecular drivers. Consecutive thyroidectomies diagnosed with multifocal PTCs ≥0.5 cm between 2019 and 2023 were reviewed. Immunohistochemistry (IHC) for BRAF VE1 was performed for all tumors. Cases with discordant BRAF IHC results or morphologic discrepancy were identified, and BRAF IHC-negative tumors were subjected to RAS Q61R IHC and/or targeted RNA next-generation sequencing. A total of 770 patients with a main PTC ≥0.5 cm were identified; 255 (33.1%) had multifocal disease, and 142 (18.4%) had at least another PTC ≥0.5 cm. Among them, 13 cases (9.2%, 13/142) had discordant molecular drivers. Twelve cases had one or more BRAF -positive PTCs accompanied by a BRAF -negative PTC (3 with CCDC6::RET fusion, 1 with NCOA4::RET fusion, 1 with ACBD5::RET fusion, 2 with ETV6::NTRK3 fusion, 1 with TG::FGFR1 fusion, 1 with LMTK2::BRAF fusion, 1 with AGK::BRAF fusion and RAS p.Q61R mutation, 1 with RAS p.Q61R mutation, and 1 without detectable molecular drivers). The last case had tumors with discordant fusion drivers ( VIM::NTRK3 and TNS1::BRAF ). Most cases showed tumors that were morphologically distinct (92.3%, 12/13) and occurred in the contralateral lobes (76.9%, 10/13). Notably, we identified 4 cases (30.8%) that presented as collision tumors and 6 cases (46.2%) that showed lymph node metastases, including 2 with simultaneous involvement by tumors with discordant molecular drivers, as novel findings. In summary, a subset (9.2%) of multifocal PTCs had discordant molecular drivers and 84.6% of them were a combination of BRAF -positive and kinase gene fusion-associated PTCs, most with distinct morphologies. Almost half of the cases had nodal metastasis and a third of them showed simultaneous involvement by tumors with discordant molecular drivers. The results highlight the clinical importance of identifying such cases, given the potentially different treatments.