Size-based expectation maximization for characterizing nucleosome positions and subtypes

Genome-wide nucleosome profiles are predominantly characterized using MNase-seq, which involves extensive MNase digestion and size selection to enrich for mononucleosome-sized fragments. Most available MNase-seq analysis packages assume that nucleosomes uniformly protect 147 bp DNA fragments. However, some nucleosomes with atypical histone or chemical compositions protect shorter lengths of DNA. The rigid assumptions imposed by current nucleosome analysis packages potentially prevent investigators from understanding the regulatory roles played by atypical nucleosomes. To enable the characterization of different nucleosome types from MNase-seq data, we introduce the size-based expectation maximization (SEM) nucleosome-calling package. SEM employs a hierarchical Gaussian mixture model to estimate nucleosome positions and subtypes. Nucleosome subtypes are automatically identified based on the distribution of protected DNA fragments. Benchmark analysis indicates that SEM is on par with existing packages in terms of standard nucleosome-calling accuracy metrics, while uniquely providing the ability to characterize nucleosome subtype identities. Applying SEM to a low-dose MNase-H2B-ChIP-seq data set from mouse embryonic stem cells, we identified three nucleosome types: short-fragment nucleosomes, canonical nucleosomes, and di-nucleosomes. Short-fragment nucleosomes can be divided further into two subtypes based on their chromatin accessibility. Short-fragment nucleosomes in accessible regions exhibit high MNase sensitivity and are enriched at transcription start sites (TSSs) and CTCF peaks, similar to previously reported "fragile nucleosomes." These SEM-defined accessible short-fragment nucleosomes are found not just in promoters but also in distal regulatory regions. Additional analyses reveal their colocalization with the chromatin remodelers CHD6, CHD8, and EP400. In summary, SEM provides an effective platform for exploration of nonstandard nucleosome subtypes.