Outcome Evaluation of a Health System Clinical Nurse Specialist Fellowship Program

Healthcare is a complex adaptive system, requiring agile, innovative leaders to transform care. Clinical nurse specialists (CNSs) are uniquely positioned to influence change and achieve high-quality outcomes. Nurse leaders need strategies to onboard and retain CNSs considering high demand across the nation. The purpose of this program evaluation was to describe the core components and outcomes of CNS fellowship programs.

This program evaluation used the Kirkpatrick Model as a framework to assess learning and knowledge translation.

The study was conducted within 3 Indiana healthcare organizations. Clinical nurse specialist leaders from each organization identified fellowship core components and analyzed team composition (ie, percentage of CNS team that was current/past fellows). Current and past CNS fellows were invited to participate in a survey evaluating program effectiveness, impact on role transition, project leadership, and outcomes achieved.

Overlap was identified among 85% (17/20) of the core components, team composition was 71% (25/35) past/current fellows, and retention was 100% (12/12). Of the 23 invited, 18 (78%) participated in the program evaluation. Program effectiveness was evaluated as very/extremely effective by 94% (17/18) of participants. Themes salient to independent practice transition were applying learning, achieving influence, and developing relationally, contributing to incremental gain of the CNS perspective (ie, CNS values and guiding principles influencing critical thinking and behavior).

Nurse leaders should consider fellowship implementation to recruit and retain CNS talent within organizations.