What Changed? Variables Associated With the General Surgery Match

Between 1994 and 2014, despite an increase in applicants, successful matches into general surgery (GS) decreased by 13%. We aim to (1) understand the trends in competitiveness for a GS residency, and ascertain the associations between (2) geographical distribution and (3) research experiences on matching.

National Resident Matching Program data (2013-2022) were analyzed for (1) annual positions and matches, (2) United States Medical Licensing Examination scores, and (3) research experiences. Geographical locations of general surgery residency programs (GSRPs) for matched US seniors were obtained from medical school websites and through contacting institutions. Distances between medical schools and respective matches were assessed for the proportion of students matching within 100 miles, in the same state or same region, or in a different geographical region than their medical school.

Of 28,690 applicants, 15,242 (53.12%) matched into a GS residency. Matched GS applicants had higher United States Medical Licensing Examination scores compared to applicants who matched in Emergency Medicine and Family Medicine (P < 0.001). US Medical Doctor (MD) match rates into GS were lower compared to Neurosurgery (P < 0.01), possibly due to competition from non-US MD applicants within GS. More applicants matched into GSRPs in the same region as their medical school, with 14% matching into home programs or within the same state as their medical school.

Higher board examination scores and research participation are associated with successful matches. GS competition from non-US MDs may be driving the match rates for US MDs lower. More than half of students matched into GSRPs in the same region as their medical school.