Investigation of oligosaccharides and allulose as sucrose replacers in low-moisture wire-cut cookies

Non-digestible oligosaccharides (OS) and allulose have beneficial health properties and could reduce the amount of added sugar in baked goods. In this study allulose and various OS [fructo-oligosaccharides (FOS), galacto-oligosaccharides (GOS), lactosucrose (LOS), isomalto-oligosaccharides (IMO), Promitor 70R (P70R), and xylo-oligosaccharides (XOS)] were added to a wire-cut cookie formulation at concentrations determined to have similar effects on the gelatinization temperature (T_gel) of starch relative to sucrose. Different baking performance attributes of the doughs and cookies were assessed, including: appearance, spread, color, texture, and % moisture loss after baking. The results were correlated to: OS solution and solid properties and OS effects on starch thermal events (gelatinization, pasting, and retrogradation). The T_gel-matching formulation protocol was effective in producing reduced-sugar cookies which had similar appearance, color, and spread attributes compared to the sucrose control; however, cookie texture significantly varied. Cookies containing allulose were the least similar to the control, having darker color, reduced spread, and softer cake-like texture. The only OS cookies that matched the texture of the sucrose control contained LOS, while P70R cookies were the hardest. Cookie texture correlated strongly with the % total moisture loss after baking (r = -0.8763) and was best explained by OS solution viscosity: more viscous OS solutions limited moisture release and resulted in harder cookies. The T_gel of starch also correlated with OS solution viscosity (r = 0.7861) and should be accounted for in reduced sugar applications. The OS recommended as sucrose replacers in cookies based on principal component analysis groupings were: XOS > IMO > LOS > and GOS.