Early Cleft Palate Repair is Associated With Lower Incidence of Velopharyngeal Insufficiency Surgery

The timing of primary repair in nonsyndromic cleft palate remains controversial. Recent evidence suggests earlier repair is associated with a lower incidence of velopharyngeal insufficiency (VPI). The authors aim to evaluate these findings in a large cohort study using causal inference.

All nonsyndromic cleft palate repairs in California were extracted between 2000 and 2021 from the California Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) database. Cases were linked with VPI surgery following cleft palate repair based on unique identifiers. The main outcome measure was incidence of VPI surgery evaluated with propensity score matching. Early cleft palate repair was defined as <7 months of age versus traditional cleft palate repair at >11 months of age. Standardized mean differences (SMD) were measured before and after matching for potential confounders including sex, race, payer, and distance from patient home to hospital.

In all, 52,007 cleft palate repairs were included, of which 12,169 (23.3%) were repaired early and 39,838 (76.7%) were repaired traditionally. Early cleft palate repairs underwent VPI surgery in 1.2% (13/1,000) of cases, compared with 6.1% (61/1000) in the traditional repair cohort. Post-matching, the average treatment effect of early repair was a 6.3% reduction in VPI surgery ( P <0.001, 95% CI -6.3, -5.4%). All covariate SMDs were <|0.1| after matching.

Our cohort study demonstrates a significantly reduced incidence of VPI surgery in children with primary cleft palate repair <7 months of age. Craniofacial centers should consider early cleft palate repair in appropriate patients.