Optimal timing for video assisted thoracic surgery decortication for improved survival in chronic empyema

Video-assisted thoracic surgery decortication for phase 3 thoracic empyema is widely accepted, but its optimal timing has not been established. We aim to investigate and assess this timing, in terms of overall survival, for chronic empyema.

Two hundred four patients with pneumonia-caused phase 3 empyema were treated with video-assisted thoracic surgery decortication over 10-years at Changhua Christian Hospital. The 90-day post-operative survival status was analyzed, and we compared the survivor group versus the non-survivor group. A receiver operating characteristic curve was used to identify the optimal decortication timing.

A comparison between survivors and non-survivors showed statistical differences among age (p=0.004), presence of cardiovascular disease (p=0.018), presence of end-stage renal disease (p=0.002), duration to surgery (p=0.013), length of intensive care unit stay (p=0.010), and overall length of hospital stay (p=0.015). ROC curve analysis determined the cut-off for video-assisted thoracic surgery decortication, based on optimal 90-day post-operative survival, to be 7.5 days after hospitalization; mortality increases threefold thereafter (14.2% vs 44.6%, p<0.001). Multivariate analysis revealed that age, end-stage renal disease, pleural effusion pH≦7.2 and duration to surgery >7.5 days negatively impacted 90-day post-operative survival.

Patients receiving decortication surgery within 7.5 days of hospital admission had better overall survival.