No Difference in Liver Damage Induced by Isocaloric Fructose or Glucose in Mice with a High-Fat Diet

Background/Objectives: The diverse effects of fructose and glucose on the progression of metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease remain uncertain. This study investigated the effects, in animal models, of high-fat diets (HFDs) supplemented with either glucose or fructose. Methods: Six-week-old, male C57BL/6J mice were randomly allocated to four groups: normal diet (ND), HFD, HFD supplemented with fructose (30% w/v, HFD + Fru), and HFD supplemented with glucose (initially 30%, HFD + Glu). After 24 weeks, liver and plasma samples were gathered for analysis. In addition, 39 patients with obesity undergoing bariatric surgery with wedge liver biopsy were enrolled in the clinical study. Results: The HFD + Glu group consumed more water than did the HFD and HFD + Fru groups. Thus, we reduced the glucose concentration from 30% at baseline to 15% at week 2 and 10% starting from week 6. The HFD + Fru and HFD + Glu groups had a similar average caloric intake (p = 0.463). The HFD increased hepatic steatosis, plasma lipid levels, lipogenic enzymes, steatosis-related oxidative stress, hepatic inflammation, and early-stage liver fibrosis. Supplementation with fructose or glucose exacerbated liver damage, but no significant differences were identified between the two. The expression patterns of hepatic ceramides in HFD-fed mice (with or without supplemental fructose or glucose) were similar to those observed in patients with obesity and severe hepatic steatosis or metabolic dysfunction-associated steatohepatitis. Conclusions: Fructose and glucose similarly exacerbated liver damage when added to an HFD. Ceramides may be involved in the progression of hepatic lipotoxicity.