Limited Availability and Readability of Spanish Language Patient Educational Material: A Review of the Nation's Top...

Cleft lip with or without cleft palate (CL/P) is a common congenital facial pathology that occurs at higher incidences in Hispanic communities. The authors analyzed the availability and readability of Spanish-written patient education materials (PEMs) on CL/P from top-ranking U.S. children's hospitals to determine the presence of health literacy barriers. Availability of PEM was evaluated by 2 methods: (1) Google search and (2) evaluation of the official hospital websites. For each institution, a Google search was conducted using the phrase, "labio leporino y/o paladar hendido (translation: CL/P) + (hospital name)." In addition, each hospital website was assessed for Spanish PEM availability. Spanish PEMs were then categorized by whether they had been generated by an automated translation function or if they were independently written Spanish text. English PEM readability was assessed using the Simple Measure of Gobbledygook (SMOG). Spanish PEM readability was assessed using spanish orthgraphic length (Spanish Orthographic Length), the SMOG converted for the Spanish language. Unpaired 2-tailed t tests were used to compare readability. Of a total of 85 pediatric hospitals, 28 (37.3%) had Spanish PEM. Five (6.7%) hospitals created their own Spanish-language document. The average spanish orthgraphic length reading level was 9.49 compared with an average SMOG of 11.38 ( P < 0.001). Institutions that did not provide Spanish PEM in any format had a significantly higher SMOG for English PEM of 12.13 compared with 11.38 of those that had SMOG with English PEM ( P = 0.04). Health literacy barriers not only exist for Spanish PEM but also for English PEM, indicating an opportunity to improve communication.