Screening of metal-modified biochars for practical phosphorus recovery

The utilization of metal-modified biochars (MBCs) for practical phosphorus recovery has attracted significant research interest recently. However, the optimal choice of metals and modification methods for MBCs remains unclear. This study addresses this gap by comparing the phosphate adsorption capabilities of various MBCs using real municipal wastewater. The results show that zinc-modified biochar exhibits superior phosphate adsorption compared to biochars modified with calcium, magnesium, aluminum, and iron. Specifically, zinc-modified biochar prepared through metal-mediated biomass pyrolysis with alkaline soaking (ZnBC-OH) demonstrates the highest adsorption capacity, achieving 36.6 mg P/g in wastewater with a phosphate concentration of 5 mg P/L. This performance surpasses that of previously reported non-lanthanide modified biochars and is comparable to lanthanide-modified biochars. Mechanistic investigations reveal that the exceptional performance of ZnBC-OH is due to the presence of highly dispersed ZnO sites, which facilitate the formation of Zn₃(PO₄)₂·4H₂O precipitation, effectively retaining phosphate. Furthermore, a techno-economic analysis indicates that using ZnBC-OH in a fixed-bed column system can reduce phosphate levels from 6 mg L^-1 to below 0.5 mg L^-1 at a cost of 1.834 USD per ton of secondary treated wastewater, underscoring its promising application potential.