Halogenated Cholesterol Alters the Phase Behavior of Ternary Lipid Membranes

Eukaryotic plasma membranes exhibit nanoscale lateral lipid heterogeneity, a feature that is thought to be central to their function. Studying these heterogeneities is challenging since few biophysical methods are capable of detecting domains at submicron length scales. We recently showed that cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) can directly image nanoscale liquid-liquid phase separation in extruded liposomes due to its ability to resolve the intrinsic thickness and electron density differences of ordered and disordered phases. However, the intensity contrast between these phases is poor compared with conventional fluorescence microscopy and is thus both a limiting factor and a focal point for optimization. Because the fundamental source of intensity contrast is the spatial variation in electron density within the bilayer, lipid modifications aimed at selectively increasing the electron density of one phase might enhance the ability to resolve coexisting phases. To this end, we investigated model membrane mixtures of DPPC/DOPC/cholesterol in which one hydrogen of cholesterol's C19 methyl group was replaced by an electron-rich halogen atom (either bromine or iodine). We characterized the phase behavior as a function of composition and temperature using fluorescence microscopy, Förster resonance energy transfer, and cryo-EM. Our data suggest that halogenated cholesterol variants distribute approximately evenly between liquid-ordered and liquid-disordered phases and are thus ineffective at enhancing the intensity difference between them. Furthermore, replacing more than half of the native cholesterol with halogenated cholesterol variants dramatically reduces the size of the membrane domains. Our results reinforce how small changes in the sterol structure can have a large impact on the lateral organization of membrane lipids.