Assessment of the Accuracy of a Deep Learning Algorithm- and Video-based Motion Capture System in Estimating Snatch...

In weightlifting, quantitative kinematic analysis is essential for evaluating snatch performance. While marker-based (MB) approaches are commonly used, they are impractical for training or competitions. Markerless video-based (VB) systems utilizing deep learning-based pose estimation algorithms could address this issue. This study assessed the comparability and applicability of VB systems in obtaining snatch kinematics by comparing the outcomes to an MB reference system. 21 weightlifters (15 Male, 6 Female) performed 2-3 snatches at 65%, 75%, and 80% of their one-repetition maximum. Snatch kinematics were analyzed using an MB (Vicon Nexus) and VB (Contemplas along with Theia3D) system. Analysis of 131 trials revealed that corresponding lower limb joint center positions of the systems on average differed by 4.7 ± 1.2 cm, and upper limb joint centers by 5.7 ± 1.5 cm. VB and MB lower limb joint angles showed highest agreement in the frontal plane (root mean square difference (RMSD): 11.2 ± 5.9°), followed by the sagittal plane (RMSD: 13.6 ± 4.7°). Statistical Parametric Mapping analysis revealed significant differences throughout most of the movement for all degrees of freedom. Maximum extension angles and velocities during the second pull displayed significant differences (p < .05) for the lower limbs. Our data showed significant differences in estimated kinematics between both systems, indicating a lack of comparability. These differences are likely due to differing models and assumptions, rather than measurement accuracy. However, given the rapid advancements of neural network-based approaches, it holds promise to become a suitable alternative to MB systems in weightlifting analysis.