Effect of beam divergence on the irradiance from dental light curing units

This study measured the beam divergence angle and light output from dental light curing units (LCUs). Twenty LCUs were assessed using a laboratory-grade wide beam imager to determine the relationship between the beam divergence on the irradiance as a function of distance from the light tip.

The irradiance (mW/cm²) and beam divergence angles (°) at 5, and 10 mm from the tips of 18 Light-Emitting Diode (LEDs), 1 Quartz-Tungsten-Halogen (QTH), and 1 Laser diode LCU.

There were significant differences in the power, irradiance, and emission spectra from the 20 LCUs. At 10 mm from the LCU tip, the irradiance delivered by one LCU decreased by approximately 85.7 %, whereas this decrease was as low as 5.6 % for a different LCU. There was a positive correlation between the divergence angle reported by the wide beam imager and the reduction in irradiance. The laser diode LCU had the least beam divergence and the smallest decrease in irradiance as the distance increased. In contrast, the QTH LCU with the turbo light guide had the greatest beam divergence and the greatest reduction in irradiance as the distance increased. 50 % of the LCUs tested would require exposure times longer than 20 s to deliver 10 J/cm² at the 10 mm distance.

The wide beam imager is a useful tool for measuring the beam divergence from LCUs and predicting the effect of distance on their irradiance. At 10 mm, some LCUs may require a fivefold increase in the exposure time to deliver the same energy they deliver at 0 mm from the tip of the LCU.