Charting a quarter-century of commercial cartilage regeneration products

Functional cartilage regeneration remains difficult to achieve despite decades of research. Dozens of commercial products have been proposed, with each targeting different facets of successful cartilage engineering, including mechanical properties, integration, lubrication and inflammation; however, there remains a lack of breakthroughs in meaningful clinical outcomes. Prior research categorized commercial products based on their components and elucidated challenges faced during the market approval process. This paper, for the first time, comprehensively reviews the properties of commercial products covering the last 25 years, including design trends in components, compatibility with minimally invasive surgery, indications for cartilage defects, long-term follow-up, as well as active sponsorship support of the International Cartilage Regeneration and Joint Preservation Society (ICRS). We aim to summarize the key factors for potentially successful commercial products and elucidate overarching trends in technology development in this field. Given that no revolutionary products have yielded significantly improved clinical results, emerging products compete with one another on user-friendliness and cost-efficiency. Other relevant characteristics include compatibility with minimally invasive surgery, extensiveness of required surgery (one-stage vs. two-stage), use of versatile artificial polymers and application of cells and biomaterials. Specific products continue to lead the market due to their cost-efficiency or indications for larger cartilage defects. However, they have been shown to result in no significant improvement upon clinical follow-up. Thus, there is a need for products that surpass current commercial products and show clinical effectiveness. Translation potential of this article: This review analyzes product components, compatibility with minimally invasive surgery, indication for cartilage defect areas, clinical performance as well as sponsorship for the World Conference of International Cartilage Regeneration & Joint Preservation Society, based on information about cartilage regeneration products from 1997 to 2023. It shines a light on future development of design and commercialization of cartilage products.