Maintaining an autocatalytic reaction system in a protocell: Nonenzymatic RNA templating and the link between...

The first protocells must have been driven by a reaction system in which autocatalysis is maintained inside the cell while food molecules outside the cell are unreactive. We show that if there is a second-order autocatalytic mechanism, then an active state can be stable inside the cell with a high catalyst concentration while the environment remains stable in an unreactive state with no catalyst. Addition of a small amount of catalyst to the environment does not cause the initiation of the autocatalytic cycle outside the cell. In contrast, for a first-order mechanism, addition of a small amount of catalyst initiates the reaction outside the cell unless there is continual removal of the catalyst from the environment. Hence, a second-order reaction mechanism maintains the difference between the inside and outside of a protocell much better than a first-order mechanism. The formose reaction, although a prebiotically plausible autocatalytic system, is first order and therefore is unlikely as a means of support for the first protocells. We give other theoretical examples of first- and second-order reaction networks but note there are few known real-world chemical systems that fit these schemes. However, we show that nonenzymatic RNA templating constitutes a second-order autocatalytic system with the necessary properties to support a protocell. Templating is maintained inside the cell but is not initiated outside the cell. If the reaction is driven by an external supply of activated nucleotides, then templating is itself a metabolic cycle. It is not necessary to have an additional separate metabolic cycle before templating reactions can occur. In this view, templating reactions, which are usually considered as the origin of replication and heredity, are also the origin of metabolism.