Unplanned extubation prevention in the neuroscience ICU at a High Reliability Organization

Intubated neuroscience ICU patients are at risk for unplanned extubation (premature removal of the endotracheal tube by the patient or during patient care). The incidence of unplanned extubation is an indicator of the quality of ICU care. Unplanned extubation is a risk factor for pneumonia, increased ventilator days, the need for tracheostomy and increased ICU and hospital length-of-stay. After serial unplanned extubations, we introduced a multidisciplinary unit-based practice standard to reduce unplanned extubations as part of a quality improvement initiative in the neuroscience ICU in a large academic medical center at a High Reliability Organization in May 2021. The unit-based practice standard to guide care of intubated neuroscience ICU patients focused on communication, timely escalation of concerns, use of sedation/analgesia targeting RASS ≤ -1, soft wrist restraints (unless specified exclusion criteria met) and continuous observation for patients at high risk of agitation/restlessness. We sought to determine the impact of this initiative on the incidence of unplanned extubations.

Unplanned extubations were identified via retrospective audit of prospective incident reports from our Patient Safety Incident registry pre-initiative (June 2020-May 2021) and prospective audit of incident reports post-initiative (July 2021-March 2024). Chart review facilitated collection of data on patient age, sex, diagnosis, intubation day, RASS goal, sedation/analgesia, restraints, constant observation, shift, and reintubation. The total number of intubated patients and ventilator days during these timeframes was identified retrospectively via an electronic medical record report of all patients on ventilators in the neuroscience ICU.

During the pre-initiative audit period, there were 214 intubated patients (968 ventilator days). The audit identified 9 unplanned extubations (0.93/100 ventilator days; 8 males, median age 63-years-old (IQR 47-67)). There were 4 patients who were not ordered for sedation/analgesia or had a RASS goal of 0 and no patients were in nonviolent soft wrist restraints. During the post-initiative audit period, there were 576 intubated patients (2,730 ventilator days). The audit identified 6 unplanned extubations (0.22/100 ventilator days; 6 males, median age 53-years-old (IQR 27-78)). All 6 patients had a RASS goal ≤ -1 and were in nonviolent soft wrist restraints.

This quality improvement initiative effectively reduced the incidence of unplanned extubations in our neuroscience ICU.