Stochastic dynamics of granular hopper flows: A configurational mode controls the stability of clogs

Granular flows in small-outlet hoppers exhibit several characteristic but poorly understood behaviors: temporary clogs (pauses) where flow stops before later spontaneously restarting, permanent clogs that last indefinitely, and non-Gaussian, nonmonotonic flow-rate statistics. These aspects have been studied independently, but a model of hopper flow that explains all three has not been formulated. Here, we introduce a phenomenological model that provides a unifying dynamical mechanism for all three behaviors: coupling between the flow rate and a hidden mode that controls the stability of clogs. In the theory, flow rate evolves according to Langevin dynamics with multiplicative noise and an absorbing state at zero flow, conditional on the hidden mode. The model fully reproduces the statistics of pause and clog events of a large (>40000 flows) experimental dataset, including nonexponentially distributed clogging times and non-Gaussian flow rate distribution, and explains the stretched-exponential growth of the average clogging time with outlet size. Further, we identify the physical nature of the hidden mode in microscopic configurational features, including size and smoothness of the static arch structure formed during pauses and clogs. Our work provides a unifying framework for several poorly understood clogging phenomena, and suggests numerous new paths toward further understanding of this complex system.