Benefits and barriers to broad implementation of genomic sequencing in the NICU

Genome (GS) and exome (ES) sequencing as first-tier diagnostic tests have the potential to increase rates of genetic diagnoses and acutely change the management of neonates in the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU). However, the widespread implementation of genomic sequencing has been limited by several barriers. In this systematic review, we analyze the current literature on the utilization of GS and ES in infants in the NICU to identify the benefits, barriers, and components of successful implementation. Across the 42 studies that discussed GS and ES in the NICU setting, six themes were identified: disease detection, timeliness of results, cost, provider attitudes, parental attitudes, and equitable access. Benefits of GS and ES include high disease detection rates, timely results, and possible reduction in healthcare costs by reducing time spent in the NICU. Additionally, clinicians find GS/ES to be important and useful, and parents and caregivers largely perceive GS/ES to be beneficial. Barriers to widespread GS/ES include availability of personnel to facilitate timely diagnosis and coverage of cost. Additionally, clinicians report worries about a lack of genetics knowledge, informed consent, results return, and potential harm. Parents consistently report low levels of anxiety, decisional conflict, harm, or regret. Finally, the lack of availability of translated consent documents limits the participation of families who do not speak English or Spanish. Continued work is essential to optimize these technologies and ensure equitable access.