A phenotypic paradigm for cerebral palsy genetics

Cerebral palsy (CP) represents a clinically and etiologically heterogeneous group of permanent but not unchanging disorders of movement, posture, and motor function resulting from non-progressive disturbances of the developing fetal or infant brain. Pathogenic variants in Mendelian disease-associated genes can be found in a subset of individuals with CP, with variants deemed causal of CP having been published for at least 515 genes. Currently, controversy exists as to whether to interpret such pathogenic variants as causing CP, whether the diagnosis instead should be "CP mimic," or whether a clinical diagnosis of CP should coexist with the molecular diagnosis of a Mendelian disease. Accordingly, there is no universally accepted model of the genetic architecture of CP. Here, we present a statistical approach that treats CP as a phenotypic feature for which some genetic disorders confer an increased risk. Based on comprehensive literature curation, we show that the null hypothesis of no CP association can be rejected for only 89 of the 515 genes. We applied these findings to the analysis of a cohort of 460 children diagnosed with CP in the Shriner Children's network who underwent genome sequencing. We identified pathogenic or likely pathogenic (P/LP) variants in 60 genes in 15.8% of the children. Only 16 of the 60 genes had significant evidence for CP association in our literature analysis. Our results suggest that a stratified approach to attributing causality to genetic variants in CP could support precision genomic medicine for affected individuals.