Functional divergence of TBP homologs through distinct DNA-binding dynamics

The TATA box-binding protein (TBP) is an evolutionarily conserved basal transcription factor common in the pre-initiation complex of all three eukaryotic RNA polymerases (RNA Pols). Despite their high conservation, homologous TBPs exhibit species- and tissue-specific functions that may contribute to the increasingly complex gene expression regulation across evolutionary time. To determine the molecular mechanisms of species- and tissue-specificity for homologous TBPs, we examined the ability of yeast TBP and murine TBP paralogs to replace the endogenous TBP in mouse embryonic stem cells (mESCs). We show that, despite the high conservation in the DNA-binding domain among the homologs, they cannot fully rescue the lethality of TBP depletion in mESCs, which correlates with their inability to support RNA Pol III transcription. Furthermore, we show that the homologs differentially support stress-induced transcription reprogramming, with the divergent N-terminal domain playing a role in modulating changes in transcriptional response. Lastly, we show that the homologs have vastly different DNA binding dynamics, suggesting a potential mechanism for the distinct functional behavior observed among the homologs. Taken together, these data show a remarkable balance between flexibility and essentiality for the different functions of homologous TBP in eukaryotic transcription.