A Comparative Study of Lesion-Centered and Severity-Based Approaches to Diabetic Retinopathy Classification:...

Background: Despite advances in artificial intelligence (AI) for Diabetic Retinopathy (DR) classification, traditional severity-based approaches often lack interpretability and fail to capture specific lesion-centered characteristics. To address these limitations, we constructed the National Medical Center (NMC) dataset, independently annotated by medical professionals with detailed labels of major DR lesions, including retinal hemorrhages, microaneurysms, and exudates. Methods: This study explores four critical research questions. First, we assess the analytical advantages of lesion-centered labeling compared to traditional severity-based labeling. Second, we investigate the potential complementarity between these labeling approaches through integration experiments. Third, we analyze how various model architectures and classification strategies perform under different labeling schemes. Finally, we evaluate decision-making differences between labeling methods using visualization techniques. We benchmarked the lesion-centered NMC dataset against the severity-based public Asia Pacific Tele-Ophthalmology Society (APTOS) dataset, conducting experiments with EfficientNet-a convolutional neural network architecture-and diverse classification strategies. Results: Our results demonstrate that binary classification effectively identifies severe non-proliferative Diabetic Retinopathy (Severe NPDR) exhibiting complex lesion patterns, while relationship-based learning enhances performance for underrepresented classes. Transfer learning from NMC to APTOS notably improved severity classification, achieving performance gains of 15.2% in mild cases and 66.3% in severe cases through feature fusion using Bidirectional Feature Pyramid Network (BiFPN) and Feature Pyramid Network (FPN). Visualization results confirmed that lesion-centered models focus more precisely on pathological features. Conclusions: Our findings highlight the benefits of integrating lesion-centered and severity-based information to enhance both accuracy and interpretability in DR classification. Future research directions include spatial lesion mapping and the development of clinically grounded learning methodologies.