Indentation stiffness of the cancellous bone in the distal human tibia

Total ankle arthroplasties tend to fail mainly on the tibial side. Fifteen fresh amputation specimens were used for assessment of the stiffness of the cancellous bone in the distal tibia. Because all current ankle replacements sacrifice the subchondral bone plate, the change in stiffness of cancellous bone was studied in transverse sections taken proximal to the subchondral plate of the ankle. The articular cartilage was removed from the tibial plafond, and serial 1-cm sections were taken, radiographed, and tested in compression on an Instron 1125 Universal Testing machine with the use of a 4-mm-diameter indentor. In the distal tibia, it was found that subchondral bone has an elastic modulus on the order of 300-450 MPa; removal of the subchondral bone plate reveals bone with a compressive resistance that is 30%-50% lower than with the bone plate intact; there is virtually no resistance to compression in the trabecular bone at a distance of more than 3 cm proximal to the subchondral bone plate; and stiffness characteristics in the distal tibia parallel the radiographic appearance of the trabeculae. The strongest cancellous bone in the region of the distal tibia is that near the subchondral bone plate. This material should be preserved, if possible, in the surgery for total ankle implants.