Systematic Review and Case Report on the Surgical Management of Pleomorphic Adenomas: Lessons on Recurrence and Error...

Background/Objectives: Pleomorphic adenomas (PAs) are the most common salivary gland tumors, with a known risk of recurrence, especially after inadequate surgical excision. Understanding how surgical approach influences recurrence remains essential to optimize management. This study aimed to synthesize recurrence rates of PAs based on different surgical techniques and to illustrate the implications of surgical strategy through a representative case of multifocal deep lobe recurrence. Methods: A systematic review was conducted according to PRISMA 2020 guidelines. Three electronic databases (PubMed, Cochrane, and Google Scholar) were searched for studies published in the last ten years, reporting recurrence rates of PAs by surgical approach. Data were extracted on recurrence, complications, and tumor characteristics. Additionally, a complex clinical case of recurrent deep lobe PA (DLPA) was presented to contextualize the findings. Results: Fifteen studies were included, comprising a total of 2095 patients. Recurrence rates were 3.27% after extracapsular dissection (ED), 0.73% after partial superficial parotidectomy (PSP), and 2.41% after superficial parotidectomy (SP). Recurrent PA (RPA) is often multifocal and associated with increased risks of facial nerve palsy and positive surgical margins. The presented case involved five surgical procedures, with ultimate total parotidectomy and facial nerve preservation despite infiltrative recurrence in the prestyloid space. Conclusions: Techniques such as ED and PSP have demonstrated their efficacy and safety compared to more invasive approaches, although their application should be carefully evaluated based on tumor size and location. RPA remains a challenging entity to treat. Avoiding outdated techniques and ensuring evidence-based decision making may improve long-term outcomes in PA management.