Assessment of Tumor Relative Biological Effectiveness in Low-LET Proton Irradiation

Background/Objectives: Within the range of spread-out Bragg peak (SOBP), LET (linear energy transfer) gradually increases from proton beam entrance point toward the beam exit direction. While it is expected that the change in LET would lead to correspondent change in RBE (relative biological effectiveness) on many human cell lines, the incomplete cell killing due to low LET can result in tumor recurrence. Hence, this study aimed to assess the RBE on different cancer cell lines along low-LET proton SOBP. Methods: The clonogenicity of A549 and Panc-1 cells after irradiation was evaluated for investigating cell radiosensitivity in response to different types of radiation. The isoeffect doses of 6-MV photon and low-LET proton beams that resulted in equivalent cell surviving fractions at proton dose of 2 or 4 Gy were compared. Results: Ratios of α/β of A549 and Panc-1 cells from photon irradiation are 51.69 and -0.7747, respectively; RBE (2 Gy proton SOBP) on A549 and Panc-1 cells are 0.7403 ± 0.3324 and 1.0986 ± 0.3984, respectively. In addition, the change in RBE with proton LET was in a cell-specific and dose-dependent manner (LET-RBE linear correlations: A549 cells [r = 0.4673, p = 0.2430] vs. Panc-1 cells at 4 Gy [r = 0.7085, p = 0.0492]; Panc-1 cells at 2 Gy [r = -0.4123, p = 0.3100] vs. 4 Gy [r = 0.7085, p = 0.0492]). Conclusions: Compared with A549 cells, Panc-1 cells present greater resistance to low-LET proton beams. In addition, currently employed generic RBE value at 1.1 for proton therapy neglected the variation in cell-/tumor-specific radiobiological responses toward different dose levels of proton beams.